Surrey provincial courthouse. (Photo: Tom Zytaruk)

Appeal court overturns Surrey sexual assault acquittal, orders new trial

Appeal court judge says Surrey court failed to consider evidence of ‘passive dishonesty’

If a person consents to have sex on condition their partner wears a condom, but their partner does not wear one, has a crime been committed?

A man who was acquitted of sexual assault by a Surrey provincial court judge will be tried once again after B.C.’s Court of Appeal overturned that verdict.

The trial judge had found no evidence of active deception.

“The question of this appeal is a simple one,” Justice Harvey Groberman explained. “Where a person consents to engage in sexual intercourse on condition that their sexual partner wear a condom, can that partner ignore the condition without being subject to criminal liability?”

Ross McKenzie Kirkpatrick was charged with sexual assault after having sex with a woman he’d met online without wearing a condom, which the court heard had been a condition of her consent.

They had sex twice, the court heard, and on the second occasion the accused, unbeknownst to the complainant, didn’t wear a condom. There is a publication ban on information that could identify the complainant.

The Crown argued before the trial judge that the consent was vitiated, or destroyed, by fraud but the judge found no evidence of fraud. The Crown appealed his decision, successfully.

Groberman found that the trial judge misinterpreted a Supreme Court of Canada case which he said, if “properly” interpreted, allows one to “validly limit their consent to sexual intercourse by insisting that a condom be used.”

The lower court judge’s interpretation, Groberman stated in his reasons for judgment, “would leave the law of Canada seriously out of touch with reality, and dysfunctional in terms of its protection of sexual autonomy.”

READ ALSO: Surrey criminal’s dangerous offender designation set aside by appeal court

READ ALSO: Appeal court orders new trial for Surrey chiropractor who was convicted of fraud

READ ALSO: Supreme court upholds Surrey judge’s no-bail order for man accused of obstructing cops

Groberman said sexual intercourse with a condom is “not the same sexual activity as sexual intercourse without a condom” and that the trial judge was “wrong in giving effect to the no-evidence motion.”

“The fact that he had, at an earlier time, agreed to use a condom is not evidence of fraud. A failure to keep a promise is not, in and of itself, fraudulent — if it were, every breach of contract would amount to a fraud,” Groberman said. “I conclude that the judge made no error in finding that there was no evidence of fraud on the part of the accused in this case.”

But, he added, “as there was evidence indicating that the accused engaged in sexual intercourse without a condom, knowing that the complainant required him to wear one, the judge erred in granting the no-evidence motion.

“In the result, I would set aside the acquittal and remit the matter to the provincial court for a new trial.”

While Appeal Court Justice Elizabeth Bennett found the trial judge was correct to find no evidence the complainant didn’t voluntarily agree to “the sexual activity in question here,” she also found there was evidence her agreement to sexual activity “was obtained by fraud and the trial judge erred in holding otherwise.

“In concluding that there was no evidence of agreement to the sexual activity of fraud that vitiated consent, the trial judge made findings of fact in relation to the element of dishonesty,” Bennett decided. “Therefore, in my view, there must be a new trial before a different judge. I would allow the appeal and order a new trial.”

“In my view, the trial judge erred in law in failing to apply the correct test for fraud, and failing to consider evidence of passive dishonesty,” Bennett said.

Justice Mary Saunders also weighed in.

“In my view, there was some evidence of fraud which obviated a no-evidence motion,” Saunders said. “For this reason, also, I consider the appeal should be allowed and the matter remitted to the Provincial Court for a new trial.”



tom.zytaruk@surreynowleader.com

Like us on Facebook and follow Tom on Twitter

CourtCriminal JusticeSurrey

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

COVID-19: Daily update on the pandemic in Surrey, White Rock and beyond

JULY 11: B.C.’s COVID-19 job recovery led by tourism, finance

Suspect in North Delta home invasion facing attempt murder charge

Blaine Robert Jackson, 37, of no fixed address, faces six charges in relation to this incident

‘Did anything good come out of my son’s overdose death?’ – South Surrey mom

Maggie Plett says action still needed on recovery homes

Rooftop hatchlings ‘a nice addition’ to White Rock RCMP operations

Pair of seagull chicks hatched in ‘fenced playground’ on July 2

PHOTOS: Surrey rally supports Mona Wang, calls for wellness check reform

Security camera footage shows Wang being dragged, stepped on during RCMP wellness check at UBCO

B.C. sees 25 new COVID-19 cases, community exposure tracked

One death, outbreaks remain in two long-term care facilities

B.C. Ferries increasing passenger capacity after COVID-19 restrictions

Transport Canada 50-per-cent limit being phased out, no current plans to provide masks

Once-in-a-lifetime comet photographed soaring over Abbotsford

Photographer Randy Small captures Comet NEOWISE in early-morning sky

BREAKING: Amber Alert for two Quebec girls cancelled after bodies found

Romy Carpentier, 6, Norah Carpentier, 11, and their father, Martin Carpentier, missing since Wednesday

Bringing support to Indigenous students and communities, while fulfilling a dream

Mitacs is a nonprofit organization that operates research and training programs

B.C. man prepares to be first to receive double-hand transplant in Canada

After the surgery, transplant patients face a long recovery

Grocers appear before MPs to explain decision to cut pandemic pay

Executives from three of Canada’s largest grocery chains have defended their decision to end temporary wage increases

Man shot dead in east Abbotsford suburbs

Integrated Homicide Investigative Team called to investigate

RCMP ‘disappointed’ by talk that race a factor in quiet Rideau Hall arrest

Corey Hurren, who is from Manitoba, is facing 22 charges

Most Read